There are setbacks. Old instincts are clingy. A night of beer and bad friends yields a robbery that goes wrong and a hurt that will take months to explain. The town’s rumor mill churns: Bad Bobby strikes again, the headlines shout, even as a woman returns a lent book and a kid gets a baseball glove left anonymously on his porch. The paradox becomes the saga’s heartbeat: people are quick to label and slower to update their copies of the story.